A Global Search for Education: In Search of Professional EthicistsDo they Exist? – Rész 1

2016-03-16-1458160052-8532420-cmrubinworldultrasound500.jpg

I see the range of professions, both in the United States and abroad, as under severe strain, because of both internal and external forces.” — Howard Gardner

In the profit-above-all-world of digitization and automation, ethics and the nature of professionalism seem to be in question and under attack from all sides. Will the new robots on the block provide the same expertise and multiple intelligences we expect from human experts? What can be done to preserve and strengthen the quality of our professions?

Today we begin a three-part blog mini-series on this topic with one of A Global Search for Education most popular contributors, Professzor Howard Gardner. In the course of our series, Howard will discuss how all the professions and, in particular education, are affected by our rapidly changing world. He will also share his recommended steps on becoming a professional ethicist.

Howard Gardner has received numerous honors throughout his lifetime, including a MacArthur prize fellowship. He has honorary degrees from universities around the globe, and has been named one of the 100 most influential intellectuals by Foreign Policy and Prospects magazine for his work in the study and exploration of the theory of multiple intelligences. He directs The GoodWork™ Project, a large scale effort to identify individuals and institutions that exemplify good work.

Rész 1 of our three-part mini blog series, Howard will discuss why he decided to start a blog about ethics in the professional world and how he thinks ethics is being undermined today.

2016-03-16-1458160086-9800509-cmrubinworld_MihaiSimonia500.jpg

For individuals who cannot afford to consult a professional, or for whom no professional is available, an artificial system will typically be much better than the recommendations of a friend or than common sensewhich is all too often common non-sense.” — Howard Gardner

Howard, why a blog calledThe Professional Ethicist”?

To begin with, Cathy, the title harbors a triple pun. Először, I don’t believe that there are such things as professional ethicists, except perhaps for the occasional philosopher. But I, along with many others, have been writing about the ethics entailed in various professions, from engineering to education. While it has improved recently, I have long been disappointed with the quality of the weekly New York Times column calledThe Ethicist”. One day last year I experienced one of those A-ha moments: “I can do it better!

Cathy, to turn serious, I believe that the range of professionsfrom architecture to veterinary medicine, from education to the ministry, are vital and precious human inventions. At the core of each of these professions is a set of values that encompass integrity, szolgáltatás, and dis-interestedness, striving to do what is right independent of personal gain or loss. Sometimes the value is distinctly personal, például, teachers have obligations to each of their students. At other times, the value veers toward the universal, például, journalists have an obligation to pursue the truth, fairly and fearlessly.

Jaj, I see the range of professions, here in the United States and abroad, as under severe strain, because of both internal and external forces. In launching my blog, I hope to explore the reasons for these pressures and the optimal means of dealing with them, thereby strengthening both the range and the quality of professions.

Do you think that robots with artificial intelligence could ultimately provide the expertise and multiple intelligences that we need from human experts?

It’s already clear that artificial intelligence can provide information that we used to secure from experts or that we had to look up ourselves. Just think about Siri, Encore, and the power of many other search engines. There is every reason to believe that these systems will continue to get ‘more intelligent’. As I am writing, the best “megy” player in the world is struggling to compete successfully with a newly developed computational system.

I think we need to separate three issues. Firstly does the system reach its ‘answersin the same way that human beings do? This is the difference between ‘artificial intelligenceand ‘human simulation. Secondly does the system manifest its intelligence? Sokunk, there’s a big difference between typing a question on our pad, as opposed to conversing with a robot or avatar. The more that the robot resembles a human being, the more satisfying it will be to many individuals, although not to me! Thirdly can the computational system provide a recommended course of action that is as solid, or even more solid, than a well-trained professional? In a way that the client finds satisfying? For the foreseeable future (say a decade or two), I think that the answer is no. But I would add that for individuals who cannot afford to consult a professional, or for whom no professional is available, an artificial system will typically be much better than the recommendations of a friend or than common sensewhich is all too often common non-sense.

2016-03-16-1458160188-5381787-cmrubinworld_gorillaimages500.jpg

We could find ourselves without an investigative press; without fair-minded judges; without physicians who prescribe what is appropriate to each patient; These outcomes would be disastrous.” — Howard Gardner

Very interesting and so back to your blog. I believe you launched it last September?

Igen, I began my blog in a very quiet way. After writing half a dozen blogs, I wrote a major essay on the future of the professions (körülbelül 5000 szavak), posted it in early December, and sent it to two dozen colleagues. I was surprised and elated by the range and depth of the responsesboth the 40 or so that have been posted and several that were sent privately. Contributors educated me about the similarities and differences between medieval guilds and modern professions; the undue power and secrecy of certain professional organizations; the different statuses and profiles of professions across Europe and Asia.

See http://www.thegoodproject.org/is-there-a-future-for-the-professions-an-interim-verdict/

Kezdetben, I had planned to write a single blog in response. But so many vital issues were brought up that I am posting ten separate blogs in the coming months.

Why do you think the ethical foundations of all professions are being undermined?

The full range of professions are vulnerable because of three major factors. Először, a smugness that the value of professions is self-evident and can therefore be taken for granted. Másodszor, the power of the marketplace which has induced many professionals across the professional landscape to chase the highest income rather than preserving the core of expert service; és végül, the digital media, which holds the promiseor the threatof replacing many, if not most tasks formerly carried out by professionals.

Taken together, these three forces would suffice to destroy the professions. További, it isn’t clear what entities/institutions/vocations could or would take their place. We could find ourselves without an investigative press; without fair-minded judges; without physicians who prescribe what is appropriate to each patient. These outcomes would be disastrous.

Join us next week for Part 2 Az In Search of Professional Ethicists, in which Howard Gardner will focus on Ethics in Education.

További információ.

2016-03-16-1458160156-5819768-cmrubinworldhowardgardnerheadshot300.jpg

C. M. Rubin és Howard Gardner

(All photos are courtesy of Shutterstock and CMRubinWorld)

GSE-logo-RylBlu

Csatlakozz hozzám és világszerte elismert szellemi vezetők többek között Sir Michael Barber (UK), DR. Michael blokk (Az US), DR. Leon Botstein (Az US), Professzor Clay Christensen (Az US), DR. Linda Darling-Hammond (Az US), DR. MadhavChavan (India), Professzor Michael Fullan (Kanada), Professzor Howard Gardner (Az US), Professzor Andy Hargreaves (Az US), Professzor Yvonne Hellman (Hollandiában), Professzor Kristin Helstad (Norvégia), Jean Hendrickson (Az US), Professzor Rose Hipkins (Új-Zéland), Professzor Cornelia Hoogland (Kanada), Tisztelt Jeff Johnson (Kanada), Mrs. Chantal Kaufmann (Belgium), DR. EijaKauppinen (Finnország), Államtitkár TapioKosunen (Finnország), Professzor Dominique Lafontaine (Belgium), Professor Hugh Lauder (UK), Lord Ken Macdonald (UK), Professor Geoff Masters (Ausztrália), Professzor Barry McGaw (Ausztrália), Shiv Nadar (India), Professzor R. Natarajan (India), DR. PAK NG (Szingapúr), DR. Denise Pope (US), Sridhar Rajagopalan (India), DR. Diane Ravitch (Az US), Richard Wilson Riley (Az US), Sir Ken Robinson (UK), Professzor Pasi Sahlberg (Finnország), Professzor Manabu Sato (Japán), Andreas Schleicher (PISA, OECD), DR. Anthony Seldon (UK), DR. David Shaffer (Az US), DR. Kirsten Magával ragadó Are (Norvégia), Chancellor Stephen Spahn (Az US), Yves Theze (LyceeFrancais számú amerikai egyesült államokbeli), Professor Charles Ungerleider (Kanada), Professzor Tony Wagner (Az US), Sir David Watson (UK), Professzor Dylan Wiliam (UK), DR. Mark Wormald (UK), Professzor Theo Wubbels (Hollandiában), Professzor Michael Young (UK), és professzor Minxuan Zhang (Kína) mivel azok feltárása a nagy kép oktatási kérdés, hogy minden nemzet ma szembesül.
A Global Search Oktatási közösségi oldal

C. M. Rubin a szerző két legolvasottabb internetes sorozat, amely megkapta a 2011 Upton Sinclair díjat, “A Global Search for Education” és “Hogyan fogjuk olvasása?” Ő a szerzője a három bestseller könyv, Beleértve The Real Alice Csodaországban, a kiadó CMRubinWorld, és egy Disruptor Alapítvány ösztöndíjasa.

Szerző: C. M. Rubin

Ossza meg ezt hozzászólás